When Your Boss Disagrees With Your Doctor

  • Over 100 Years of Experience

    Our dedicated attorneys have a reputation for success.

    Meet Our Team
  • Our Awards Set Us Apart

    Learn about our distinguishing awards & how this benefits you.

    What It Means For You
  • Client Testimonials

    Many satisfied clients have used Schwartz Perry & Heller.

    What They Have to Say
  • Request Your Consultation

    Contact our firm today to learn how we can help you.

    Get Started Now

When Your Boss Disagrees With Your Doctor

When Your Boss Disagrees With Your Doctor

Fast-food worker says boss made her flush her medication

Employees on medical leave who are directed to return to work or be fired …

Staffers who are told to continue doing their job duties despite medical restrictions …

Workers whose bosses refuse to allow them time off for medical treatment …

Unfortunately, it’s not uncommon for workers to find themselves stuck between their employer’s demands and their doctor’s instructions.

The scenarios above are just a few examples of potentially unlawful treatment that individuals are subjected to every day.

A recent case illustrates the difficult position workers may find themselves in when their employers try to override medical orders.

Let’s look at what happened in this case and then discuss what it means to you.

‘You need Jesus, not medication”

Cynthia Dunson worked as a shift manager for a Kentucky Fried Chicken (KFC) franchise. During her employment, she claims she performed all of her job duties without issue.

However, Dunson says that she was fired because of her boss’s preconceived notions about certain medications that Dunson was taking.

Here’s what happened: one day Dunson casually mentioned to her boss that she needed to leave to get to a therapy appointment on time. She added that she was under a doctor’s care and taking medication.

She claims that her boss asked what medications she was taking. After Dunson disclosed the medications, she says that her boss replied, “You cannot take that sh*t and work here.” He then allegedly demanded that she flush her medications down the toilet, and sent another manager with her to be a witness. The boss also allegedly stated that Dunson “needed Jesus, not medication.”

After her next shift, Dunson says that her boss accused her of being high on her medication. She assured him that she had disposed of all of it.

Dunson saw her doctor, who became alarmed that Dunson had abruptly stopped her medication because doing so was unsafe. Dunson called her employer while at the doctor so she could explain that she was under medical orders to resume her prescriptions. She alleges that her boss told her not to listen to listen to her doctor.

The doctor directed Dunson to stay out of work for the weekend. Dunson says that her boss told her that she would not be allowed to come back to work if she was going to let “her doctor put things in her head.” Dunson stated that she was going to follow her doctor’s instructions.

She was fired.

Dunson complained to the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC), which is now suing on her behalf. The EEOC claims that Dunson is disabled under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) because her bipolar disorder limits her neurological functioning, and that her employer made prohibited medical inquires and then fired her for her disability.

Now it will be up the company to defend its decision to fire Dunson.

Learn more about this case here.

What it means to you

According to the EEOC, the agency in charge of enforcing federal anti-discrimination laws, employers may only ask about medical conditions under two circumstances:

  1. If the employer needs medical documentation to support an employee’s request for an accommodation, or
  2. The employer has reason to believe an employee would not be able to perform a job successfully or safely because of a medical condition

In this case, the employee claims that she was able to successfully perform all of her job duties. Dunson made no requests for accommodation.

Contact us now

If you believe that your rights have been compromised because of a medical condition or disability, it’s a good idea to speak to an attorney.

Call or email us today to discuss your unique situation.


No Comments Posted

Contact Us

Schwartz Perry & Heller LLP
New York Employment Law Attorney
Located at: 3 Park Ave.,
27th Floor,

New York, NY 10016
View Map
Phone: (646) 490-0221
Local Phone: (212) 889-6565
© 2018 All Rights Reserved.


The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.